![]() ![]() As this work seeks to address the increasingly diverse religious landscapes of the United States and Europe, the authors have missed an opportunity to be in conversation with scholars of Islam and further deconstruct the socio-religious divides that allow for illiberal democracy to prosper.Īlthough the book contains in-depth historical and political analyses of circumstances in the United States and abroad, it is written in an accessible manner which allows it to be read widely-from classrooms to places of worship and beyond. Islam is a major world religion with monotheistic theology, akin to Judaism and Christianity. While the book offers theological responses to illiberal democracy from Jewish and Christian perspectives-notably reflective of the authors’ own backgrounds-a theological response from an Islamic perspective is noticeably missing. Their work challenges faith leaders and laypersons alike to do the same and join together across seemingly insurmountable boundaries to work towards a global emphasis on human rights and dignity for all people. In the act of penning Faith, Nationalism, and the Future of Liberal Democracy, Elcott and his coauthors have come together across religious and cultural divides and exemplified a clear commitment to liberal democracy. Finally, chapter 6 turns to Jewish pluralism as “an effective way to partner with God” and names any absolutist claim as “idolatry” (149, 146). Similarly, chapter 5 calls for Protestant communities to learn from their historical “failures” and heed the advice of Bonhoeffer to oppose injustice and aid its victims (130–132). Chapter 4 urges Catholic faith leaders to educate their communities on the history and tradition of the Catholic Church and the “integral relationship between Catholic teachings on human rights and the institutions that protect and promote them” (112). The latter half of the book moves beyond the question, “how did we get here?” to the follow-up question, “where do we go from here?” Each of the last three chapters focuses on a single religious response: Catholicism, Protestantism, and Judaism, respectively. Building from this analysis, chapters 4, 5, and 6 offer theological responses to illiberal democracy. Chapters 2 and 3 analyze populism in Europe and nationalism in the United States, offering current and historical examples of each. The rest of the book can be separated into two sections. Furthermore, liberal democracies foster discourse across differences to ensure human rights and dignity for all people regardless of class, creed, or nationality. In contrast, liberal democracies share a commitment to democratic norms, by “ the political legitimacy of opponents, violence as a force for change, and the civil liberties of opponents, media, and vulnerable populations” (31). Illiberal democracies “seek to purify the nation, which they see as tainted or even poisoned by alien forces, often in a combination of race, ethnicity, and religious identity” (28). Leaders in illiberal democracies often “invoke the majority’s religion as the foundation of the state” to create further divides (5). They are marked by the act of othering those who appear to fall outside of “the majority” in each context. Illiberal democracies are engendered through an amalgamation of “populism, nationalism, and religious identities” (5). The introduction and chapter 1 work together to begin describing this dichotomy. The hopeful, yet pragmatic project of this book rests on the authors’ distinctions between liberal and illiberal democracies. Primarily using examples from the United States and European contexts, Elcott and his coauthors carefully outline the historical and political factors that have led to this moment and offer an array of theologically grounded solutions for bolstering liberal democracy. Colt Anderson, Tobias Cremer, and Volker Haarmann attempts to answer the resounding question, “how did we get here?” The here in question is the contemporary moment in which illiberal democracy, undergirded with the sentiment of “religious identity as a prerequisite for national membership,” is flourishing (18). Written on the heels of the 2020 United States presidential election and amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, Faith, Nationalism, and the Future of Liberal Democracy by David M. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |